NZ Farmers' online trading resource

Farming News Archive | Newsletter | Farmer's View

Retention of Producer Ownership

Greetings Readers

ENZA has become a classic demonstration of the conflicts in values between a producer driven cooperative structure and a corporate based return on capital profit driven structure.

Critics of the Dairy industry’s cooperative structure have made great play of the inability of producers to fund growth for industry development and pointed to the need for tradable shares.

However, the disaster that is now being presented to individual apple growers as a corporate dominated marketing structure puts legal expediency ahead of business morality. This is a warning that there are no conditions where producers should mix ownership of, and responsibility for, the structure that pays for the products they have processed and marketed with the inducements of innovative management and marketing conditional on equity investment.

The ease with which the ENZA directors have proceeded to put their organisation ahead of the survival of growers is a shocking warning that grower’s interests are not the same as the interests of corporates seeking financial advantage.

The unnecessary mixing of corporate shareholding with grower cooperation has been the downfall of ENZA. The only folk with a clear objective in the ENZA debacle are the raiders perusing a course of disruption and dislocation for their own ends and the real producers have been left sidelined, bewildered and without help, big losers..

What a price to pay for inattention to the detail of ownership.

Good farming

NZ Internet Services Ltd - website developers and website designers New Zealand
All content copyright © 2003 Farmnet | Legal Disclaimer